Making your venture more fundable by removing potential red flags
This is another question I have had to deal with and have got asked in the past. How do you structure a business, or hire or develop a startup in a way not to turn off the VC’s at a later stage. You have to consider the cap table, the business location and structure, the team, the investor base and many more things.
Do not start-up without considering the long term objectives of the business and its funding path – in other words consider all the issues for the life of the business at the start, as far as you can, and then get going.
As you go along try and make sure you minimize issues and actions that will lead to problems when it comes to funding at each stage. In particular, VC’s are very sensitive to all manner of issues and will pass on a deal that takes too much effort to "clean up".
I read an excellent and funny piece that deals with this in detail on infoChachkie.com, where he refers to the issue as "deal hair".
Shining, Gleaming, Steaming, Flaxen, Waxen
Deal hair, just like the real thing, comes in a variety of colors and styles. Some of the most common types of deal hair include:
Junky Capitalization Table – A hodgepodge of small investors that could cause potential headaches for management and/or institutional investors.
- Nair Solution – Repurchase as much stock as is practical and convert any remaining preferred stockholders to common stock status.
Untenable Bridge Terms – Convertible debt terms that are prohibitive to an institutional investment, such as large discounts and/or warrant coverage that dilutes the intuitional investor’s investment.
- Nair Solution – Marginalize the relative dilutive impact of these terms. For instance, a discount of less than twenty percent is usually deemed reasonable. In addition, converting warrant coverage to non-participating status will also enhance your adVenture’s fundability.
Band of Brothers – Friends, family, former roommates and other unqualified people occupy senior management positions.
- Nair Solution – Replace such mis-hires with strong-willed, independent executives who have relevant, successful track records.
IP Confusion – Questionable ownership of key intellectual property, including non-exclusive licenses, potential infringement of a third party’s technology and/or inappropriate use of open-source tools.
- Nair Solution – In most failed adVentures, the only asset of value upon dissolution is the underlying intellectual property. As such, it is paramount that investors can unequivocally evaluate its veracity.
Legal Landmines – No matter how frivolous, lawsuits will seriously chill investors’ interest.
- Nair Solution – As noted in Roping In The Legal Eagles, it is generally advantageous to fight nuisance lawsuits to avoid becoming known as easy mark for unscrupulous lawyers. However, when fundraising, it is more appropriate to expeditiously resolve any litigation (potential or otherwise), rather than expend energy convincing a skeptical investor that your legal issues are without merit.
Geographic Dispersion – Significant physical separation of Core Team.
- Nair Solution – During an adVenture’s early days, virtual teams are often viable. However, as a company accelerates its growth by deploying its institutional funding, the Core Team cannot afford to be handicapped by disparate locales. As such, the Core Team should be prepared to relocate to a central location within a reasonable period after obtaining funding.
Way Outsourcing – Outsourcing core competencies.
- Nair Solution – Identify the areas of your adVenture that are critical to its success and internally develop the necessary levels of core competency. For instance, technology startups should maintain key development resources in-house, rather than relying exclusively on third-party, contract labor. If your business model is predicated on superior online marketing expertise, do not utilize consultants to craft and execute your online marketing initiatives.
Double Agent – Problematic agency issues, such as high salaries, non-entrepreneurial perks (car allowances, exorbitant travel expenditures, etc.), side businesses and/or cross-ownership of related businesses.
- Nair Solution – The addition of disciplined, experienced investors to your adVenture team will require you to run your business with a focus on creating long-term value. As such, eliminate any unconventional forms of compensation or other potential areas of Agency conflict before you are forced to do so by a prospective investor.
Before you seek investment capital, do what you can to make your adVenture smooth and shiny, with no nicks or cuts. Although judicious use of metaphorical Nair on your adVenture will help your fundraising efforts, it is often also necessary to unequivocally acknowledge the remaining deal hair. It should be shampooed, conditioned and styled in the most attractive manner possible. Trying to cover up deal hair with a cap and deny its existence is not a viable strategy. If you remove and groom the hair on your deal, there will be no doubt as to “Who loves ya baby?”
See the full article here: http://www.infochachkie.com/nair/
Learn from the guru on presentations…it’s harder than you think to build a compelling pitch
Again and again I find myself telling my MBA students about how to present.
They tend to get everything wrong, every time, no matter how many times I tell them or ask them to learn.
Why? Well it’s probably because it’s very hard to “simplify” ideas and then present them in an easy to understand way, especially if you are very highly educated!
I find it very hard myself and I think it’s an art that people don’t spend enough time on or invest in…communicating clearly for almost all my MBAs is key to their final results and yet they leave it to the last minute, prepare badly, present badly and produce terrible materials…
So I am writing a quick post to set them on the straight and narrow once and for all and I hope this helps you too!
As they are all very busy I want to summarize my guru (Garr Reynolds) on the core things you need to know and then suggest you invest in his excellent book right away: Presentation Zen.
Organization & Preparation Tips
http://www.garrreynolds.com/Presentation/prep.html
Top Ten Delivery Tips
http://www.garrreynolds.com/Presentation/delivery.html
Top Ten Slide Tips
http://www.garrreynolds.com/Presentation/slides.html
Some sample slides
http://www.garrreynolds.com/Presentation/sample1.html
How to develop the right slide design by Guy Kawasaki
How to Change the World: The 10/20/30 Rule of PowerPoint
See my other posts on presenting and investor pitches:
- The Six Minute -No Slides- Angel Presentation
- Even more advice on presenting to investors…preparation is key
- Why startup pitches fail
- Top questions you may be asked during an investment presentation
- How to present to a VC to win
- The definitive guide on how to present to Angels (by angels)
- Key things you must do when presenting to win
Even more advice on presenting to investors…preparation is key
You must know what they say about the 5 P’s, preparation prevents “piss poor” performance!
THE PREPARATION PROCESS:
Identify the 3-5 key points you want the audience to remember. These will inevitably be the key points of the investment case. Build the presentation (or meeting) around these points.
Limit the amount of information you give an audience, so that they don’t have any difficulty identifying the key points.
Start with a strong statement, after which all your comments should reinforce the opening. The strong start should provide a theme for the presentation, which can be pulled together by reference to it at the end (e.g. “I said right at the start….”). That start may be your key message, or the reason why they should listen to your story.
Back up key points with evidence in the form of facts and figures, but also use examples, analogies, metaphors, anecdotes and success stories to bring issues, especially abstract areas, alive and make them memorable. Every-day examples are best. Use just enough evidence to provoke interest in and discussion of the key point. That way the Q&A discussion is more likely to be centred around what you said i.e. the key points of the investment case you want them to agree with and remember.
In general, look through your notes/script, once created, to see what visuals are needed. Visual aids should reinforce and clarify your message, not lead the presentation. By using visual aids to illustrate a point made by the speaker, the audience will see who is in control and gain a more positive impression of you the management team. If using slides, make sure that there are some blank slides in the presentation, to ensure that the audience’s attention returns to the speaker.
If you are writing a script (only suitable for use with larger audiences, make sure it is written in spoken not grammatical English. Keep sentences short and snappy and break them up with dots ( …. ) to encourage conversational delivery. Use contractions such as “we’re” rather than “we are” and avoid literary, weak words such as “however” and “therefore” – use “but” and “so.”
All audiences have limited attention spans. Short presentations are better than longer ones. A maximum of twenty minutes is a good guide.
Close dramatically. Summarize the key points and end on an upbeat note by referring to your strong start and reinforcing – conversationally – the investment case.
How To Create A Unique Selling Proposition
This is a superb piece by Jay Abraham on creating your USP.
I really like his many books and reference materials and suggest you take a look at them if you are in sales or marketing.
This is a direct quote from one of his articles, see the reference to his web site at the end of the piece.
Even while you creatively imitate others, remember that it’s also important to be different. Distinguish your business or practice from all the rest. Make your enterprise special in the eyes of your customer or client. That is the goal I want you to pursue.
How do you get your business differentiated? By creating a Unique Selling Proposition – or USP.
A USP is that distinct and appealing idea that sets you and your business, or practice, favorably apart from every other generic competitor. The long-term marketing and operational successes I help you achieve will, ultimately, be helped or hurt by the USP you decide upon.
The possibilities for building a USP are unlimited. It’s best, however, to adopt a USP that dynamically addresses an obvious void in the marketplace that you can honestly fill. Beware: It’s actually counter-productive to adopt a USP if you cannot fulfill the promise.
Most business owners don’t have a USP, only a "me too," rudderless, nondescript, unappealing business that feeds solely upon the sheer momentum of the marketplace. There’s nothing unique; there’s nothing distinct. They promise no great value, benefit, or service — just "buy from us" for no justifiable, rational reason.
It’s no surprise then that most businesses, lacking a USP, merely get by. Their failure rate is high, their owners are apathetic, and they get only a small share of the potential business. But other than a possible convenient location, why should they get much patronage if they fail to offer any appealing promise, unique feature or special service?
Would you want to patronize a firm that’s just "there," with no unique benefit, no incredible prices or selection, no especially comforting counsel, service or guarantee? Or would you prefer a firm that offers you the broadest selection in the country? Or one with every item marked up less than half the margin other competitors charge? Or one that sells the "Rolls Royce" of the industry’s products?
Can you see what an appealing difference the USP makes in establishing a company’s perceived image or posture to the customer? It’s ludicrous to operate any business without carefully crafting a clear, strong, appealing USP into the very fabric of the daily existence of that business.
The point is to focus on the one niche, need or gap that is most sorely lacking, provided you can keep the promise you make.
You can even create hybrid USPs — combinations that integrate one marketing gap with another. Before you decide on a USP, though, be sure you can always deliver that USP through your whole organization. You and your staff must consistently maintain high levels of quality or service.
If you decide your USP is that your company offers the broadest selection of products or services "instantly available" or "always in stock," but in reality you only stock six out of 25 items and only a few of each item, then you’re falling down on the essence of your USP promise, and your marketing will probably fail. It is critical to always fulfill the "big promise" of your USP.
If you don’t honestly believe you can deliver on your USP, pick another one to build your business on. Just be sure it’s unique and that you can fulfill it.
Remember, the USP is the nucleus around which you will build your success, fame, and wealth, so you better be able to state it. If you can’t state it, your prospects won’t see it. Whenever a customers needs the type of product or service you sell, your USP should bring your company immediately to mind.
Clearly conveying the USP through both your marketing and your business performance will make your business great and success inevitable. But you must reduce your USP to its sinewy bare essence.
Try it. With paper and pen, prepare a one-paragraph statement of your new USP. At first, you will have trouble expressing it tightly and specifically. It may take two or three paragraphs or more. That’s okay. Ruthlessly edit away the generalities, and tenaciously focus on the crispest, clearest, most specific promise you could possibly hold out. Then, rework it and hack away the excess verbiage or hazy statements until you have a clearly defined, clearly apparent Unique Selling Proposition a customer can immediately seize upon. And then, integrate your USP into every marketing aspect of your business, such as display advertising, direct mail and field selling.
Let’s say you run display-type ads, and your USP is that you have better selection and follow-up service than any other competitor. There are several ways to integrate these qualities into your ads. For example: State the selection USP in the ad headline:
"We Always Have 168 different Widgets in No Less than 12 Different Sizes and 10 Desirable Colors, in price ranges from $6 to $600."
Or, if good service at an affordable price is your USP, use this as a model:
"ABC Tree Trimmers will trim and maintain your trees and shrubs six times a year, once every two months, and all it costs you is $16 a month, billed quarterly."
By now you should have the general idea that you should carefully integrate your newly adopted USP into the headline and body copy of every ad you run. And in every direct-mail piece you send out.
But integrating your USP into just your ads and mailing pieces isn’t enough. You must integrate its positioning statement into every form of your marketing. When your salespeople call on prospects, everything they say should clearly reinforce your USP. They should explain the USP to the customer in a clear, concise statement. For example:
"Hello, Mr. Prospect. I know your time is short, so I’ll get right to the point. Your company manufactures widgets. You buy steel and copper from a competitor. You’re currently paying $100 a ton for steel and $75 a ton for copper, of which you waste roughly 25%. My firm will sell you a higher grade steel and a higher alloy copper for $95 and $69 a ton, respectively, freight prepaid, which saves you an extra $3 a ton. Plus, we’ll guarantee our metal will produce a waste factor of 15% or less, and we’ll replace any wasted coverage, free. One last point, Mr. Prospect. It could be important. We’ll furnish you with 50, 20 gauge titanium rivets and cap assemblies free with every 10 tons of steel you order this month. May I have your order?"
Throughout the sales pitch, your sales reps should refer to the USP benefits or advantages, showing the prospect why it’s vastly superior to take advantage of your USP rather than your competitor’s USP, if he or she even has one.
Don’t try and merely have your salespeople "wing it." Insist that they do their homework. Make them sit down (figuratively speaking) and express the essence of your USP. Be sure they can clearly and powerfully express your USP in 60 seconds (the oral equivalent of a written paragraph), and then compellingly state how it benefits the prospect. Furnish your prospects with plenty of examples of how you honestly deliver your USP.
When an old, tired company or profession adopts a powerful, new, and appealing USP, it gives new life, new excitement, new interest and new appeal to the marketing plan. You’re suddenly different, instead of just being another interloper preying on customers you’ve trapped into hearing your sales pitch! Now you’re on the customer’s side.
However, remember this axiom: You will not appeal to everybody. In fact, certain USPs are designed to appeal to only one segment of a vast market. There is a vast gulf between the upscale clients and the bargain seekers, and you probably can’t reach them both. Which do you want to stake out as your market niche?
Don’t forget my earlier advice. Don’t adopt a USP that you can’t deliver, or further marketing is useless. Also, analyze the market potential of various USP positions in terms of volume, profits and repeat business.
For example, the highest marketing niche may be in the exclusive, expensive USP, but the biggest money may be made in the discount-volume USP. There’s a place for both, but if you try to ride two horses, you’ll probably bite the dust. Remember too, that your USP is giving advice, assistance and superior service; it can’t stop with mere sales rhetoric. It must become total company conduct. If someone calls in with a question, the people answering the call must extend themselves. The same goes for every person who interacts with that customer, from the cashier and the delivery person to the service or repair people. You and your employees must live, breathe, and act your USP at all times.
Sit down and write a synopsis of your USP for your staff, how you’re trying to carry it out, and how everyone can project that USP to the world. Make their cooperation a condition of employment. The entire company must adhere to the USP.
Talk to your staff, write scripts, hold contests, and reward people who distinguish themselves in promoting your USP. Set an example so that your staff can see the USP in action.
How can you ensure that you are in the hearts and minds of your customers after the sale? Here are a few good approaches:
Immediately following a sale, write, call or visit your customers. During this follow-up effort, see that the customers feel important and special, and that their initial purchases are "resold." Repeat your USP and remind the customers how it helped them make their purchasing decision. Reassure customers about their wise decisions, and show how the same USP that served them this time will be there to serve them in the future.
And again, state your USP, telling customers why you’ve adopted it, and why it’s such an advantage to them. People rarely understand the benefits you provide them, unless you carefully educate them to appreciate your efforts on their behalf.
A post-purchase follow-up incorporating the essence of your USP is vital, regardless of how frequently you "back-end" or resell to that customer. You enhance the customer’s loyalty and value to your business by following up after the sale. At the very least, a follow-up call, letter, or sales appeal drastically reduces or eliminates cancellations, returns, refunds, complaints, adjustments and disputes, and reassures customers of the prudence of their recent purchase.
Good marketing requires that you give customers rational reasons for their emotional buying decision. There is a formula for success, and the USP, my dear friends, is truly an integral part of that formula.
Depending on the business, I usually advise my clients to offer frequent special promotions to their customers by mail, telephone or in person. Everyone wants to feel appreciated and personally acknowledged. By offering your customers genuine, specially priced deals or first choice, you endear yourself to them. At the same time, you enhance your customers’ perception of your Unique Selling Proposition.
If your USP is service, your preferred promotions will be service-based rather than price-based. Give them extended service — for instance, a special offer of your basic service, or one year of free consulting or assistance not normally given.
Also, don’t underestimate the profit potential inherent in special offers. Acquiring first-time customers usually costs a small fortune. Space ads have to reach tens of thousands of readers to produce a few hundred customers, so it may cost you $10 or more to acquire a customer. The same goes for TV, radio, or direct mail. Field salespeople may have to call on 15 to 30 prospects before they make one sale, so the cost of acquiring a new customer may be "hundreds" of dollars.
But once you satisfactorily deliver your product or service and have a core customer base, you can continuously rework and resell at a very modest cost per sale. When you have a list of customers who have already shown their willingness to spend money on your products or services, it costs very little to go to them with additional special offers.
If you have 10,000 customers, it will probably cost $3,000 to mail them a letter. (At best, that same $3,000 for display advertising would probably generate only 100 new customers at a cost of $30 per customer.) Calling all 10,000 prospects on the phone would take five telephone sales people about a month. If they were on salary, that might cost you about $10,000 (for that month) or only about $1.00 a contact.
If broad choice is your USP, have a customer-service representative contact your customers to see if everything is satisfactory. If everything is not, offer to replace, repair or correct the product or service. Your customer-service people should know just as much about available choices and options as your salespeople. Give them reasonable authority to replace, repair or reinstall if there is any dissatisfaction. Make them aware that their jobs depend on ensuring that the promise behind your USP is fulfilled. They should provide evidence to any customer with a problem, complaint or question that the USP is real and that the entire company is enthusiastically committed to doing whatever it takes to promptly fulfill the USP promise.
Anyone in your employ who does not, cannot, or will not promote your USP should be immediately replaced with someone who can and will. Your real wealth comes from repeat or residual business which will only happen if every aspect of your business is a continuous extension of your USP.
You can send a personal thank-you note, letter, or a computer-typed letter to customers. You can send a gift or a gift certificate. You can send items to correspond with holidays: A box of candy on Valentine’s Day; a poinsettia, a turkey or ham at Christmas; a birthday card — the possibilities are many. If you add up the customer’s value in future business or repeat sales, you can probably justify a sizable investment in his or her goodwill. Everyone likes to be acknowledged and feel they are special.
You should even integrate your USP into every contact with dissatisfied customers!
Whenever someone asks for a refund, replacement, or adjustment, instead of resenting the fact that you have to give back money, use that opportunity to reconvey the essence of your USP — either in person or by letter. If you have an exchange department, instruct that staff to courteously and sincerely reiterate your firm’s USP, and assure the dissatisfied customer of the firm’s commitment to offer more service, greater selection, better guarantees or whatever. Then, if you issue credit or a check, include a prepared letter expressing your deep commitment to your USP, and apologizing for any inconvenience, disappointment or dissatisfaction. With every refund, send a letter expressing disappointment that you did not fulfill the customers expectations, and strongly restate your firm’s USP and your commitment to it.
Then ask the dissatisfied customer to please give you another chance to make good! And make it worth their while by giving them a discount certificate, a special bonus, offering three widgets for the price of two, or some other preferential treatment that shows unhappy customers you want their business back, that you appreciate them, and that you will make good.
Above everything else, never, ever lose track of the fact that USP is all about the customer or the client. It is not about me, you, the company or the profession. Don’t make the mistake of aggrandizing your business. Instead, help your customer or client do some aggrandizing.
Abraham Publishing • 27520 Hawthorne Blvd. Suite 263
Rolling Hills Estates, CA 90274 • 310-265-1840
Website: www.abraham.com
Always, always, always get references when hiring…
How to get references
Always get references as a way to Exclude candidates and get them very early.
Always check: 2 bosses, 2 Peers, 2 Staff, 2 Customers and other colleagues/VCs etc.
Also, try to get other non-provided names to give a view of the candidate if possible for a totally independent view.
The Email to collect refs:
Dear X,
We are a software business considering Paul for the position of VP Sales, US.
He has provided your name as a reference for him and I would appreciate a few moments of your time to help us understand his character along with his suitability for the Job?
We are a software business that is launching into an aggressive market – Digital Rights Management – we need someone that can plan, open doors to key decision makers, present and close $1-20M+ plus revenues annually. Our clients will be everyone from small to large ISVs/software developers and publishers.
This person must also be able to manage themselves and their time to the optimum effect, usually working on their own account and do all the relevant paperwork that goes with a high level job like this. Finally they must be able to recruit, manage and motivate sales staff.
Could you give me your views on his ability to do this effectively along some insight into his character?
-How do you know Paul and what is your view of him as a person? (Honesty, integrity, tenacity, loyalty and ability)
-How long have you known him?
-How does he stack up against other VP Sales you know?
-What would you say are his best and worst skills?
-In what areas does he need improvement?
-What are your thoughts on his work ethic?
-Would you hire him (again)?
Your views will help a great deal.
Many thanks and warm regards,
You
————————–
Always try and get a phone call as many people will not tell the truth on paper and the refs will likely be "friends" or good connections anyway and you are likely to get a better feel if they are poor quality refs via the phone than email!





